Did U.S. Execute Osama bin Laden?

Did U.S. Execute Osama bin Laden?

The killing of Osama bin Laden is beginning to look like little more than a standard IDF targeted killing.  Initially, the Obama administration clearly stated that bin Laden was armed and resisted.  Now, the account has been radically revised.  He wasn’t armed, but ‘resisted’ in some unspecified way.  There is only one way to satisfy speculation in this matter.  They have to release documentary footage of the moment of his killing to allow people to judge for themselves what happened.  Not the pictures of his dead body, which they weighting the release of now.  Given the radical discrepancies, it’s no longer a situation in which we can take the government’s word for what happened.

If Bin Laden resisted violently I would have no problem with his killing.  If he resisted passively, there surely are ways to disable someone without killing them as they did his wife, who they shot in the leg but did not kill.

In the situation of Israeli targeted killings and anti-terror operations, the victims are often killed either in bed or unarmed.  While there is always a claim that violent resistance was offered, the evidence often does not support this.  That is why the Bin Laden operation is beginning to sound suspiciously like an IDF one.

I’m rapidly coming to the conclusion that this was simply an execution, not an apprehension.  And that it was always intended to be an execution, contrary to what the government told us when they said they were prepared to capture him if he didn’t resist violently.

The fact too that Bin Laden’s body was buried almost immediately at sea seems deeply strange to me.  Why do you so fear someone’s dead body that you make it disappear?  Not to mention that disposing of his earthly remains in such a way would be a deep offense even to those many Muslims who despise Bin Laden.  This is more or less what the Russians did to Hitler’s remains.  They wanted to leave no trace of him for his supporters to worship.  As a result, the way they disappeared his body will become a bone of contention for years and decades to come.

I didn’t fear Bin Laden alive and I don’t fear him dead.  We are better and stronger than anything he represented.  But when we execute our enemies and disappear their remains we aren’t behaving much better than they do.

On a completely different subject, I’ve wondered why those who built this compound for Bin Laden didn’t build a panic room that couldn’t be penetrated by the type of force which invaded it and ended up killing him.  If he had retreated to such a sealed bunker he could’ve waited out the onslaught and the arrival of Pakistani forces, who might’ve ended it and forced the U.S. forces to retreat.  Did Al Qaeda not think that such an assault was possible?  If so, they were guilty of hubris.  I’m not suggesting this because I particularly wanted to protect Bin Laden or see him saved.  If the Pakistanis had captured him his fate might not have been much different.  But I’m just curious about the thinking of those who protected Bin Laden and why something that occurred to me didn’t occur to them.

Related posts:

  1. Bin Laden is Dead, Long Live Bin Laden No, I haven’t become an Al Qaeda fan and I’m…
  2. Israeli Border Police Summarily Execute Palestinian Hit and Run Driver How’s this for “driving while Arab?”  Now, keep in mind…
  3. ADL Says ‘No’ to Park51 Ground Zero Muslim Cultural Center, Claims ‘Survivors’ Entitled to Be Racist Abe Foxman, one of American Jewry’s leading Islamophobes, announced the…
This entry was posted in Afghanistan, Background & Analysis, Bin Laden, Counterinsurgency, Events, Human Rights, Imperialism, Military, Obama. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s